Throughout, B B B , Q m , j Q_{m,j} Q m , j β , J m J_{m} J m β , E m E_{m} E m β and Ο n \sigma_{n} Ο n β are as in Uniform Grids on a Half-Open Box and Grid Hulls of a Compact Set in R n \mathbb{R}^n R n , for the parameters c c c and s s s chosen in step 2 below. We use the bilinearity and symmetry of the dot product (The Dot Product on R n \mathbb{R}^n R n Is Symmetric, Bilinear and Positive Definite ) and the properties of the Euclidean norm collected in Properties of the Euclidean Norm on R n \mathbb{R}^n R n : Square, Distance, Vanishing, Coordinate Bounds, Homogeneity, Triangle Inequalities and Expansion of a Square .
Step 1: K K K and T ( K ) T(K) T ( K ) are compact Borel sets of finite measure. Since K K K is nonempty, so is T ( K ) T(K) T ( K ) . Being compact, K K K belongs to B ( R n ) \mathcal{B}(\mathbb{R}^{n}) B ( R n ) and satisfies Ξ» n ( K ) < β \lambda_{n}(K)<\infty Ξ» n β ( K ) < β by claim 3 of Balls Have Positive Lebesgue Measure and Bounded Sets Have Finite Lebesgue Measure ; moreover K K K is bounded and closed by The Heine-Borel Theorem in R n \mathbb{R}^n R n , and Compactness of Closed Balls and the Unit Sphere . Fix z β R n z\in\mathbb{R}^{n} z β R n and a real R > 0 R>0 R > 0 with d E ( z , x ) β€ R d_{E}(z,x)\le R d E β ( z , x ) β€ R for every x β K x\in K x β K , and fix x β β K x_{\ast}\in K x β β β K .
The set T ( K ) T(K) T ( K ) is bounded: for x β K x\in K x β K , the triangle inequality for d E d_{E} d E β gives β₯ x β x β β₯ = d E ( x β , x ) β€ d E ( x β , z ) + d E ( z , x ) β€ 2 R \lVert x-x_{\ast}\rVert=d_{E}(x_{\ast},x)\le d_{E}(x_{\ast},z)+d_{E}(z,x)\le 2R β₯ x β x β β β₯ = d E β ( x β β , x ) β€ d E β ( x β β , z ) + d E β ( z , x ) β€ 2 R , whence d E ( T ( x β ) , T ( x ) ) = β₯ T ( x ) β T ( x β ) β₯ β€ 2 L R d_{E}\bigl(T(x_{\ast}),T(x)\bigr)=\lVert T(x)-T(x_{\ast})\rVert\le 2LR d E β ( T ( x β β ) , T ( x ) ) = β₯ T ( x ) β T ( x β β )β₯ β€ 2 L R .
The set T ( K ) T(K) T ( K ) is closed. Let ( w ( q ) ) q β N (w^{(q)})_{q\in\mathbb{N}} ( w ( q ) ) q β N β be a sequence in T ( K ) T(K) T ( K ) converging to w β R n w\in\mathbb{R}^{n} w β R n , and for each q q q choose x ( q ) β K x^{(q)}\in K x ( q ) β K with T ( x ( q ) ) = w ( q ) T(x^{(q)})=w^{(q)} T ( x ( q ) ) = w ( q ) . By The Bolzano-Weierstrass Theorem in R n \mathbb{R}^n R n there are x β R n x\in\mathbb{R}^{n} x β R n and a strictly increasing sequence ( q t ) t β N (q_{t})_{t\in\mathbb{N}} ( q t β ) t β N β in N \mathbb{N} N with ( x ( q t ) ) (x^{(q_{t})}) ( x ( q t β ) ) converging to x x x ; since K K K is closed, x β K x\in K x β K by Sequential Characterization of Closed Subsets of a Metric Space . Let Ξ΅ β R \varepsilon\in\mathbb{R} Ξ΅ β R with 0 < Ξ΅ 0<\varepsilon 0 < Ξ΅ , and choose t t t with β₯ x ( q t ) β x β₯ < Ξ΅ / ( 2 L + 2 ) \lVert x^{(q_{t})}-x\rVert<\varepsilon/(2L+2) β₯ x ( q t β ) β x β₯ < Ξ΅ / ( 2 L + 2 ) and β₯ w ( q t ) β w β₯ < Ξ΅ / 2 \lVert w^{(q_{t})}-w\rVert<\varepsilon/2 β₯ w ( q t β ) β w β₯ < Ξ΅ /2 . Then
β₯ w β T ( x ) β₯ β€ β₯ w β w ( q t ) β₯ + β₯ T ( x ( q t ) ) β T ( x ) β₯ < Ξ΅ 2 + L β Ξ΅ 2 L + 2 β€ Ξ΅ . \lVert w-T(x)\rVert\le\lVert w-w^{(q_{t})}\rVert+\lVert T(x^{(q_{t})})-T(x)\rVert<\frac{\varepsilon}{2}+L\,\frac{\varepsilon}{2L+2}\le\varepsilon . β₯ w β T ( x )β₯ β€ β₯ w β w ( q t β ) β₯ + β₯ T ( x ( q t β ) ) β T ( x )β₯ < 2 Ξ΅ β + L 2 L + 2 Ξ΅ β β€ Ξ΅ .
As Ξ΅ \varepsilon Ξ΅ was an arbitrary positive real number and 0 β€ β₯ w β T ( x ) β₯ 0\le\lVert w-T(x)\rVert 0 β€ β₯ w β T ( x )β₯ , we get β₯ w β T ( x ) β₯ = 0 \lVert w-T(x)\rVert=0 β₯ w β T ( x )β₯ = 0 , hence w = T ( x ) β T ( K ) w=T(x)\in T(K) w = T ( x ) β T ( K ) by claim 3 of Properties of the Euclidean Norm on R n \mathbb{R}^n R n : Square, Distance, Vanishing, Coordinate Bounds, Homogeneity, Triangle Inequalities and Expansion of a Square . By Sequential Characterization of Closed Subsets of a Metric Space the set T ( K ) T(K) T ( K ) is closed, and being bounded it is compact by The Heine-Borel Theorem in R n \mathbb{R}^n R n , and Compactness of Closed Balls and the Unit Sphere ; claim 3 of Balls Have Positive Lebesgue Measure and Bounded Sets Have Finite Lebesgue Measure then gives T ( K ) β B ( R n ) T(K)\in\mathcal{B}(\mathbb{R}^{n}) T ( K ) β B ( R n ) with Ξ» n ( T ( K ) ) < β \lambda_{n}(T(K))<\infty Ξ» n β ( T ( K )) < β .
Step 2: a half-open box containing K K K . Put R 1 = β₯ z β₯ + R R_{1}=\lVert z\rVert+R R 1 β = β₯ z β₯ + R . For x β K x\in K x β K the triangle inequality gives β₯ x β₯ β€ β₯ z β₯ + β₯ x β z β₯ β€ R 1 \lVert x\rVert\le\lVert z\rVert+\lVert x-z\rVert\le R_{1} β₯ x β₯ β€ β₯ z β₯ + β₯ x β z β₯ β€ R 1 β , hence β£ x i β£ β€ β₯ x β₯ β€ R 1 |x_{i}|\le\lVert x\rVert\le R_{1} β£ x i β β£ β€ β₯ x β₯ β€ R 1 β for every i β [ n ] i\in[n] i β [ n ] by claim 4 of Properties of the Euclidean Norm on R n \mathbb{R}^n R n : Square, Distance, Vanishing, Coordinate Bounds, Homogeneity, Triangle Inequalities and Expansion of a Square . Let c β R n c\in\mathbb{R}^{n} c β R n have every component equal to β R 1 β 1 -R_{1}-1 β R 1 β β 1 and put s = 2 R 1 + 2 s=2R_{1}+2 s = 2 R 1 β + 2 , a positive real number. Then for x β K x\in K x β K and i β [ n ] i\in[n] i β [ n ] ,
c i = β R 1 β 1 < β R 1 β€ x i β€ R 1 < R 1 + 1 = c i + s , c_{i}=-R_{1}-1<-R_{1}\le x_{i}\le R_{1}<R_{1}+1=c_{i}+s , c i β = β R 1 β β 1 < β R 1 β β€ x i β β€ R 1 β < R 1 β + 1 = c i β + s ,
so K β B K\subseteq B K β B , the half-open box of Uniform Grids on a Half-Open Box and Grid Hulls of a Compact Set in R n \mathbb{R}^n R n determined by c c c and s s s .
Step 3: the covering estimate. Let Ξ΅ β R \varepsilon\in\mathbb{R} Ξ΅ β R with 0 < Ξ΅ 0<\varepsilon 0 < Ξ΅ . Since K K K is nonempty, compact and contained in B B B , the exhaustion of a compact set by grid hulls provides a mesh index m β N m\in\mathbb{N} m β N (one of the m k m_{k} m k β there) with
Ξ» n ( E m ) β€ Ξ» n ( K ) + Ξ΅ . \lambda_{n}(E_{m})\le\lambda_{n}(K)+\varepsilon . Ξ» n β ( E m β ) β€ Ξ» n β ( K ) + Ξ΅ .
Write h = s / m h=s/m h = s / m , J = J m J=J_{m} J = J m β and E = E m E=E_{m} E = E m β . By the grid-hull properties , J J J is nonempty and finite with Ξ» n ( E ) = β£ J β£ β h n \lambda_{n}(E)=|J|\,h^{n} Ξ» n β ( E ) = β£ J β£ h n ; put p = β£ J β£ p=|J| p = β£ J β£ and let g : [ p ] β J g:[p]\to J g : [ p ] β J be a bijection, as in Number of Elements of a Set .
For every u β [ p ] u\in[p] u β [ p ] the set Q m , g ( u ) β© K Q_{m,g(u)}\cap K Q m , g ( u ) β β© K is nonempty by the definition of J J J , so Choice for a Family Indexed by a Finite Set provides points z ( u ) β Q m , g ( u ) β© K z^{(u)}\in Q_{m,g(u)}\cap K z ( u ) β Q m , g ( u ) β β© K , one for each u β [ p ] u\in[p] u β [ p ] . Put Ξ² = L β Ο n β h \beta=L\,\sigma_{n}\,h Ξ² = L Ο n β h , a nonnegative real number, and
W u = { w β R n : β£ w i β T ( z ( u ) ) i β£ β€ Ξ² Β Β forΒ everyΒ i β [ n ] } ( u β [ p ] ) . W_{u}=\bigl\{w\in\mathbb{R}^{n}:\bigl|w_{i}-T(z^{(u)})_{i}\bigr|\le\beta\ \text{ for every }i\in[n]\bigr\}\qquad(u\in[p]). W u β = { w β R n : β w i β β T ( z ( u ) ) i β β β€ Ξ² Β Β forΒ everyΒ i β [ n ] } ( u β [ p ]) .
Each W u W_{u} W u β is the product over i β [ n ] i\in[n] i β [ n ] of the sets { t β R : T ( z ( u ) ) i β Ξ² β€ t β€ T ( z ( u ) ) i + Ξ² } \{t\in\mathbb{R}:T(z^{(u)})_{i}-\beta\le t\le T(z^{(u)})_{i}+\beta\} { t β R : T ( z ( u ) ) i β β Ξ² β€ t β€ T ( z ( u ) ) i β + Ξ² } , which are intervals with endpoints differing by 2 Ξ² 2\beta 2 Ξ² and hence Borel subsets of R \mathbb{R} R of Lebesgue measure 2 Ξ² 2\beta 2 Ξ² by claim 4 of Lebesgue Measure on the Real Line: Existence, Lengths of Intervals and Uniqueness . By Lebesgue Measure on R n \mathbb{R}^n R n , W u β B ( R n ) W_{u}\in\mathcal{B}(\mathbb{R}^{n}) W u β β B ( R n ) and Ξ» n ( W u ) = ( 2 Ξ² ) n \lambda_{n}(W_{u})=(2\beta)^{n} Ξ» n β ( W u β ) = ( 2 Ξ² ) n .
Let x β K x\in K x β K . Since K β E K\subseteq E K β E there is u β [ p ] u\in[p] u β [ p ] with x β Q m , g ( u ) x\in Q_{m,g(u)} x β Q m , g ( u ) β , and z ( u ) z^{(u)} z ( u ) also lies in that cell, so the diameter bound for a grid cell gives β₯ x β z ( u ) β₯ β€ Ο n h \lVert x-z^{(u)}\rVert\le\sigma_{n}h β₯ x β z ( u ) β₯ β€ Ο n β h . Both x x x and z ( u ) z^{(u)} z ( u ) lie in K K K , so
β₯ T ( x ) β T ( z ( u ) ) β₯ β€ L β β₯ x β z ( u ) β₯ β€ L β Ο n h = Ξ² , \bigl\lVert T(x)-T(z^{(u)})\bigr\rVert\le L\,\lVert x-z^{(u)}\rVert\le L\,\sigma_{n}h=\beta , β T ( x ) β T ( z ( u ) ) β β€ L β₯ x β z ( u ) β₯ β€ L Ο n β h = Ξ² ,
and claim 4 of Properties of the Euclidean Norm on R n \mathbb{R}^n R n : Square, Distance, Vanishing, Coordinate Bounds, Homogeneity, Triangle Inequalities and Expansion of a Square gives β£ T ( x ) i β T ( z ( u ) ) i β£ β€ Ξ² |T(x)_{i}-T(z^{(u)})_{i}|\le\beta β£ T ( x ) i β β T ( z ( u ) ) i β β£ β€ Ξ² for every i β [ n ] i\in[n] i β [ n ] ; that is, T ( x ) β W u T(x)\in W_{u} T ( x ) β W u β . Hence
T ( K ) β β u = 1 p W u , T(K)\subseteq\bigcup_{u=1}^{p}W_{u}, T ( K ) β u = 1 β p β W u β ,
and by claims 2 and 4 of Basic Properties of a Measure (the latter applied to the sequence W 1 , β¦ , W p , β
, β
, β¦ W_{1},\dots,W_{p},\varnothing,\varnothing,\dots W 1 β , β¦ , W p β , β
, β
, β¦ ),
Ξ» n ( T ( K ) ) β€ β u = 1 p Ξ» n ( W u ) = p β ( 2 Ξ² ) n = p β ( 2 Ο n L ) n h n = ( 2 Ο n L ) n Ξ» n ( E ) β€ ( 2 Ο n L ) n ( Ξ» n ( K ) + Ξ΅ ) . \lambda_{n}\bigl(T(K)\bigr)\le\sum_{u=1}^{p}\lambda_{n}(W_{u})=p\,(2\beta)^{n}=p\,\bigl(2\sigma_{n}L\bigr)^{n}h^{n}=\bigl(2\sigma_{n}L\bigr)^{n}\lambda_{n}(E)\le\bigl(2\sigma_{n}L\bigr)^{n}\bigl(\lambda_{n}(K)+\varepsilon\bigr). Ξ» n β ( T ( K ) ) β€ u = 1 β p β Ξ» n β ( W u β ) = p ( 2 Ξ² ) n = p ( 2 Ο n β L ) n h n = ( 2 Ο n β L ) n Ξ» n β ( E ) β€ ( 2 Ο n β L ) n ( Ξ» n β ( K ) + Ξ΅ ) .
Step 4: conclusion. Put a = Ξ» n ( T ( K ) ) a=\lambda_{n}(T(K)) a = Ξ» n β ( T ( K )) , b = Ξ» n ( K ) b=\lambda_{n}(K) b = Ξ» n β ( K ) and C = ( 2 Ο n L ) n C=(2\sigma_{n}L)^{n} C = ( 2 Ο n β L ) n ; by step 1 these are nonnegative real numbers. Step 3 shows that a β€ C β ( b + Ξ΅ ) a\le C\,(b+\varepsilon) a β€ C ( b + Ξ΅ ) for every positive real Ξ΅ \varepsilon Ξ΅ . Suppose C β b < a C\,b<a C b < a . If C = 0 C=0 C = 0 then a β€ 0 = C β b a\le 0=C\,b a β€ 0 = C b , contradicting C β b < a C\,b<a C b < a ; so 0 < C 0<C 0 < C , and taking Ξ΅ = ( a β C β b ) / ( 2 C ) \varepsilon=(a-C\,b)/(2C) Ξ΅ = ( a β C b ) / ( 2 C ) , a positive real number, gives
a β€ C β b + C β Ξ΅ = C β b + a β C β b 2 = a + C β b 2 < a , a\le C\,b+C\,\varepsilon=C\,b+\frac{a-C\,b}{2}=\frac{a+C\,b}{2}<a, a β€ C b + C Ξ΅ = C b + 2 a β C b β = 2 a + C b β < a ,
a contradiction. Hence a β€ C β b a\le C\,b a β€ C b , that is, Ξ» n ( T ( K ) ) β€ ( 2 Ο n L ) n Ξ» n ( K ) \lambda_{n}(T(K))\le(2\sigma_{n}L)^{n}\lambda_{n}(K) Ξ» n β ( T ( K )) β€ ( 2 Ο n β L ) n Ξ» n β ( K ) .