TheoremBase

Proof

Throughout, BdXB_{d_X}, BdYB_{d_Y} and BdXΓ—YB_{d_{X\times Y}} denote open balls in the respective metric spaces, and we write s<ts<t for real numbers s,ts,t to mean that s≀ts\le t and sβ‰ ts\ne t.

Step 0: balls of the product metric are products of balls. Let (x,y)∈XΓ—Y(x,y)\in X\times Y and let rr be a real number with 0<r0<r. For (xβ€²,yβ€²)∈XΓ—Y(x',y')\in X\times Y, claim 3 of The Product Metric is a Metric says that dXΓ—Y((x,y),(xβ€²,yβ€²))<rd_{X\times Y}((x,y),(x',y'))<r holds if and only if dX(x,xβ€²)<rd_X(x,x')<r and dY(y,yβ€²)<rd_Y(y,y')<r. Hence

BdXΓ—Y((x,y),r)=BdX(x,r)Γ—BdY(y,r).B_{d_{X\times Y}}\bigl((x,y),r\bigr)=B_{d_X}(x,r)\times B_{d_Y}(y,r).

Step 1: metric openness implies membership in the product topology. Let WW be open in (XΓ—Y,dXΓ—Y)(X\times Y,d_{X\times Y}) and let (x,y)∈W(x,y)\in W. By the definition of an open subset of a metric space there is a real number r>0r>0 with BdXΓ—Y((x,y),r)βŠ†WB_{d_{X\times Y}}((x,y),r)\subseteq W. Put U=BdX(x,r)U=B_{d_X}(x,r) and V=BdY(y,r)V=B_{d_Y}(y,r). By Open Ball in a Metric Space is Open we have U∈TXU\in\mathcal{T}_X and V∈TYV\in\mathcal{T}_Y, and by Step 0

(x,y)∈UΓ—V=BdXΓ—Y((x,y),r)βŠ†W,(x,y)\in U\times V=B_{d_{X\times Y}}\bigl((x,y),r\bigr)\subseteq W ,

where (x,y)∈UΓ—V(x,y)\in U\times V because dX(x,x)=0<rd_X(x,x)=0<r and dY(y,y)=0<rd_Y(y,y)=0<r by condition 2 in the definition of a metric. As (x,y)∈W(x,y)\in W was arbitrary, WW belongs to the product topology.

Step 2: membership in the product topology implies metric openness. Let WW belong to the product topology and let (x,y)∈W(x,y)\in W. Choose U∈TXU\in\mathcal{T}_X and V∈TYV\in\mathcal{T}_Y with (x,y)∈UΓ—VβŠ†W(x,y)\in U\times V\subseteq W. Since x∈Ux\in U and UU is open in (X,dX)(X,d_X), there is a real number r1>0r_1>0 with BdX(x,r1)βŠ†UB_{d_X}(x,r_1)\subseteq U; likewise there is r2>0r_2>0 with BdY(y,r2)βŠ†VB_{d_Y}(y,r_2)\subseteq V. By claim 9 of Elementary Order Arithmetic in an Ordered Field there is a real number rr with r≀r1r\le r_1, r≀r2r\le r_2, and rr equal to r1r_1 or to r2r_2; in either case 0<r0<r.

Let (xβ€²,yβ€²)∈BdXΓ—Y((x,y),r)(x',y')\in B_{d_{X\times Y}}((x,y),r). By Step 0 we have dX(x,xβ€²)<rd_X(x,x')<r and dY(y,yβ€²)<rd_Y(y,y')<r, so claim 2 of Elementary Order Arithmetic in an Ordered Field gives dX(x,xβ€²)<r1d_X(x,x')<r_1 and dY(y,yβ€²)<r2d_Y(y,y')<r_2, that is xβ€²βˆˆBdX(x,r1)βŠ†Ux'\in B_{d_X}(x,r_1)\subseteq U and yβ€²βˆˆBdY(y,r2)βŠ†Vy'\in B_{d_Y}(y,r_2)\subseteq V. Hence

BdXΓ—Y((x,y),r)βŠ†UΓ—VβŠ†W.B_{d_{X\times Y}}\bigl((x,y),r\bigr)\subseteq U\times V\subseteq W .

As (x,y)∈W(x,y)\in W was arbitrary, WW is open in (XΓ—Y,dXΓ—Y)(X\times Y,d_{X\times Y}).

Steps 1 and 2 give the stated equivalence, and therefore the equality of the two collections of subsets of XΓ—YX\times Y.

Citations

Loading…

Dependencies

Uses0

Loading…

Comments

Log in to comment.

Loading…